Alabama Law Blog

White Tiger Graphics v. Clemons, Case No. 2100482 (January 13, 2012)

Monday, January 23, 2012
Issues: Judicial Estoppel, Receipt of Unemployment Compensation on Workers' Compensation Claim.

Clemons sued White Tiger, a printing business, seeking workers' compensation benefits. Clemons alleged that he injured his left knee and right shoulder in work-related accidents. Clemons' employment was terminated in late 2009 and subsequently received unemployment benefits from the State Department of Industrial Relations. Following a trial on the workers' compensation claim, the trial court awarded Clemons permanent total disability benefits. On appeal, White Tiger argued that Clemons was judicially estopped from claiming that he was disabled because in order to receive unemployment compensation he had to be "physically and mentally able to perform work of a character which he is qualified to perform by past experience or training." The Court of Civil appeals held that receipt of unemployment compensation did not bar a worker from claiming total disability. According to the Court, "Clemons' assertion to D IR that he was willing and able to perform some work that he was qualified to do is not totally inconsistent with his claim to be permanently and totally disabled for workers' compensation purposes."

Evening and weekend hours are available by appointment

FREE cosultations are available in Alabama and for out-of-state clients

Review us on Google Places

Office Location

Joseph A. Ingram
3928 Montclair Road
Suite 208
Mountain Brook, AL 35213
Phone: 205 - 335 - 2640

Please call us at

205-335-2640
or send us an email