Skip to Content
Call Today for a Consultation (205) 506-5590 205-335-2640

Challenging the Chains: A Legal Analysis of Probation Revocation and Sentencing Disputes


In a legal landscape where every detail counts, the case of Kendall Ramone Spencer v. State of Alabama emerges from the Mobile County Circuit Court, presenting a compelling narrative on the intricacies of probation revocation and the legality of split sentences. This case not only highlights the complexities inherent in criminal sentencing but also underscores the critical importance of adhering to statutory requirements, offering valuable insights for legal practitioners and defendants alike.

In April 2022, Kendall Ramone Spencer faced convictions for first-degree and second-degree assault, leading to a sentencing that would later spark considerable legal debate. The circuit court's decision to impose a 20-year imprisonment sentence, credited for "time served," followed by a five-year probation period, was called into question. Spencer had served approximately one year, five months, and 23 days prior to sentencing—a period significantly shorter than the three-year minimum split sentence mandated by § 15-18-8(a)(2), Alabama Code 1975, for his offense.

The crux of Spencer's appeal rested on the contention that the "time served" component of his sentence was unlawfully short, rendering the circuit court's subsequent probation revocation for these convictions legally invalid. Spencer's argument leaned heavily on the precedent set by Ex parte McGowan, asserting that a sentence unauthorized by statute exceeds the jurisdiction of the trial court and is, therefore, void.

The State countered, suggesting that the use of "time served" fell within the circuit court's jurisdiction to suspend the unserved balance of the minimum three-year split term under § 15-18-8(g), Alabama Code 1975. This interpretation, however, was not upheld by the Court, which found the State's argument to misunderstand the legislative intent and the precedent established by Ex parte McCormick.

Ultimately, the Court sided with Spencer, concluding that his split sentence for the first-degree assault conviction was unauthorized and, thus, void under the cited statutory and case law. This decision not only vacated the probation revocation order related to this conviction but also set a precedent for how similar cases might be approached in the future. The ruling emphasizes the judiciary's role in adhering to statutory guidelines and the potential for legal redress when procedural errors occur.

For individuals navigating the criminal justice system, this case serves as a poignant reminder of the significance of legal representation well-versed in the nuances of criminal law. It underscores the importance of scrutinizing sentencing details and probation conditions, as well as the potential avenues for appeal when discrepancies arise.

At Ingram Law, our commitment to justice and meticulous legal representation is unwavering. Whether you're facing complex criminal charges or challenging probation revocation orders, our expertise in criminal defense and family law stands as a beacon of hope and advocacy. The case of Kendall Ramone Spencer v. State of Alabama is a testament to the difference that skilled legal intervention can make, highlighting the potential for overturning unjust decisions and safeguarding the rights of the accused.

In the realm of criminal justice, where the stakes are invariably high, understanding the legal landscape is paramount. As this case demonstrates, the path to justice often requires navigating a labyrinth of statutes, precedents, and judicial interpretations—a journey best undertaken with experienced legal counsel by your side.

If you are facing a criminal law case call Joseph A. Ingram or Ingram Law LLC, at (205) 335-2640. Get Relief * Get Results


Contact Ingram Law Today

Request a Consultation by Filling Out This Form
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy